I wrote previously, and at some length, that in the good old 19th century days of mass immigration, back when the future Lady Liberty's "give me your tired, your poor" mantra was actually taken literally, Christmas was celebrated by the teeming masses more in the spirit of Halloween than in the current "traditional" version which Charles Dickens made so sentimentally popular with his tale of the miser who suddenly gets "woke" by his nightmares and who salves his conscience by giving his clerk's family one opulent Christmas dinner, one measly raise, and one lousy day off.
Back in the good old days, working class holiday revelers acted like the Gilets Jaunes of France. They assailed the wealthy by wassailing the wealthy in a winter form of Trick or Treat. Give us money and a decent wage and some of your food, or we'll smash things. That unrest spurred the rich propertied classes to bring their own Yuletide revelry behind their bolted doors. They encouraged poor people to follow their example, and just stay the hell home.
Dickens could even be considered the literary precursor of neoliberalism and trickle-down economics. His poverty-stricken, orphaned heroes in his most popular books ultimately prevail. They survive and come out of penury not through the imposition of taxes on the aristocracy, with the upshot of a more equitable society, but in the miraculous discovery of some long-lost aristocratic relative. David Copperfield finds his wealthy aunt, Oliver Twist is rescued by a benevolent gentleman who turns out to be his grandfather, Esther Summerson (one of the few Dickensian female characters who isn't a complete simpering dolt) both inherits a bundle and finds true love despite a smallpox-scarred countenance. Naturally, these lucky few had mothers who were either sluts, improvident, dumb, or all three. The heroes were selfless bootstrappers who overcame adversity through hard work, grit, maybe a little honest theft, and determination -- and long-lost benefactors.
Pip in Great Expectations is somewhat of an outlier in the Dickens canon. He goes through several transformations, from naive child, to snobbish gentleman, to "woke" individual who finally overcomes his snootiness and finds some humanity after discovering that his particular benefactor is a convicted felon. He even gets to marry the benefactor's snooty daughter in the Hollywood film version.
It isn't until Dickens' later novels that he examines wealth inequality and societal injustice. From going to "living happily ever after" upon the acquisition of riches, his characters come to realize that money is no guarantee of a happy life. His last work, Our Mutual Friend, proved unpopular with both the critics and the public because it turned the rags to riches myth right on its head. The family at the center of the book inherits a ton of cash, and misery and vacuity and conspicuous, tasteless consumption ensue.
I used to be a fan, but now I'm just not that into A Christmas Carol, whose moral value to the modern-day wealthy is that it permits them to be stingy and selfish on the other 364 days of the year. The working class as portrayed by the Cratchits were meekly accepting of their lot, as all of us should be. Christmas is still largely an indoor festival, and not just because it's cold outside. And it's that one special time of year for the ruling class to wear their noblesse oblige proudly on their sleeves for the relative minute out of their lives that it takes to play Santa. And then they ostentatiously send the video clips of their good deeds to all the news sites and networks to ensure that the gratefully quiet rabble won't miss even one second of their conspicuous, yet fleeting, beneficence.
Case in point:
And since Barack Obama has always prided himself on his "balanced approach" to inequality, here's Mrs. Claus in a pair of glittery, gaudy $4,000 boots whose material appears to have been prised right off the walls of Trump's Fifth Avenue Versailles palace and then glued directly onto what Victorian writers in the age of Dickens so delicately used to describe as "limbs."
(Sorry for the Santa redundancy at the end of the above clip, but it was the least gushy and the shortest that I could find from my Google search of this vapid event.)
If this approach still isn't quite balanced enough for you, then do check out Santa Barack's recent visit to a Neocon think tank in Houston, where he shamed a whole roomful of Oil and Gas titans out of $5 million of their polluted cash. Not for sick children, mind you, but to help promote his Mutual Friends in the Neoliberal World Order Club.
The problem of the super-wealthy and the ruling class, folksily lectured Obama to the oligarchs, is that they haven't adapted quickly enough to the mass disaffection of the dispossessed rabble. The elites are just too smug, he smugly remarked, to much appreciative smug laughter and applause from the elite audience. They wouldn't recognize a veiled insult if it hit them like a gentle ocean breeze. Them selfish? They are Thought Leaders whose only goal is to make the world a better place.
God bless us, everyone.
ReplyDeleteAlong that line, note this commentary:
"Beto O'Rourke is the new Obama. And that's the last thing we need,"
by David Sirota --
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/dec/22/beto-orourke-voting-record-2020-election-democrats
May Donald Trump and all the fossil fuel fanatics get their stockings stuffed with coal.
And for the rest of us, may we find the wisdom and fortitude to do what needs to be done, and the grace and gratitude to care for the natural world and all its creatures.
Blessings to you, Karen, and to all your kind, concerned, and conscientious readers.
Make merry, make peace, and stay bright.
Another great column.
ReplyDeleteHere it is again, the joyful Christmas Season. BTW, cute hat, Obama; as for the gown, Michelle,––if that is a gown––and those boots, straaaange.
ReplyDeleteA ridiculously useless passage from the Bible ought to round out this sentimental picture. Let's skip the Bethlehem bit and jump ahead to one of the parables. How about Luke 16:19-31, slightly edited for contemporary readers?
The Rich Man and Lazarus
19 There was this rich guy who was dressed in bespoke suits and fine linen and lived in luxury every day. His wife was decked out in spun gold. At his gate was camped a homeless guy on cardboard, covered with sores, a bit loopy in the head, and longing to eat what fell from the rich guy's table. Even the dogs came and licked his sores.
Too soon the homeless guy died and the angels carried him to Abraham’s side. Eventually, the rich guy also died. In Hades, where he was in torment, he looked up and saw Abraham far away, with the homeless guy by his side. So he called to him, ‘WTF, Father Abraham, have pity on me and let the homeless guy dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue, because I am in agony in this fire.’
But Abraham replied, ‘Hey, pal, remember in your lifetime you received an abundance of good things, while the not-so-lucky received bad things and you couldn't care less? Now they are comforted up here and you are in agony down there. In any event, between us and you a great chasm has been set in place, so that those who want to go from here to you cannot, nor can anyone cross over from there to us. It's a lot like the chasm you created between the 1% and the 99%.’
The rich guy answered, ‘Then I beg you, father Abraham, send the homeless guy to my family, for I have five brothers, some of whom are sell-out politicians. The homeless guy can clue them in so they will not, like me, come to this place of torment.’
Abraham replied, ‘They have Gandhi, Weil, King, the Berrigans, Nader, Picketty and all the rest; let them listen to them.’
'Right, father Abraham,’ he said, ‘but if someone from the dead, like me, goes to them, they will repent.’
Abraham said to him, ‘If they don't listen to the prophets I just mentioned, they won't be convinced even if someone rises from the dead. In the meantime, have you thought about bootstrapping your way out of there?'
Let there be Peace on Earth and let it begin in Syria!
ReplyDeleteSanta needs to confiscate Barack Obama's Nobel Peace Prize and deliver it to the White House tomorrow for Donald J. Trump. He needs all the encouragement he can get to counter the grief he's getting from the bipartisan War Party.
"WTF,Father Abraham" made me LOL for realsies when I read it. Thanks, Jay! A very Merry Christmas to u and all our fellow Sardonickists around the world. :)
ReplyDeletehttps://youtu.be/dPUwv_20p5I
I just got this Christmas card from my Congressman. Looks like they're putting a positive spin on the discretionary money they indiscriminately shoveled into the Pentagon.
ReplyDeleteOn the twelfth day of Christmas
The Congress bought for you:
Twelve lasers marking
Eleven snipers aiming
Ten tanks a blitzing
Nine missiles soaring
Eight mines for laying
Seven subs a diving
Six printers printing
Fiiiive bill-yuuuun buuuucks ...
Four drones a circling
Three nukes refurbished
Two boondoggles pending
And a flattop on the rising seas.
Have a kickass Christmas, everybody, and a hell of a New Year.