For one brief shining moment this past weekend, the New York Times broke out of its role as establishment mouthpiece and publicist for the powerful, and practiced some real journalism.
"Hidden Pentagon Records Reveal Patterns of Failure In Deadly Airstrikes" was the banner headline of the two-part blockbuster written by Azmat Khan. Of course, euphemizing the US government's decade-long campaign of drone terror and mass murder of civilians in the middle East as a tactical "failure" is the very essence of Timesianism.
Still, it's the body of the two-part piece, based upon a five-year-long investigation by the Times - including successful Freedom of Information lawsuits for Pentagon records, visits by reporters to the cratered, ruined physical sites of the atrocities, and interviews with survivors - that should be horrifying all who read it, and more than enough to call Congress back into session to start a full investigation and a full public airing of the smoking gun evidence of some of the worst war crimes in all of recorded history.
Khan writes,
The trove of documents — the military’s own confidential assessments of more than 1,300 reports of civilian casualties, obtained by The New York Times — lays bare how the air war has been marked by deeply flawed intelligence, rushed and often imprecise targeting, and the deaths of thousands of civilians, many of them children, a sharp contrast to the American government’s image of war waged by all-seeing drones and precision bombs.
The documents show, too, that despite the Pentagon’s highly codified system for examining civilian casualties, pledges of transparency and accountability have given way to opacity and impunity. In only a handful of cases were the assessments made public. Not a single record provided includes a finding of wrongdoing or disciplinary action. Fewer than a dozen condolence payments were made, even though many survivors were left with disabilities requiring expensive medical care. Documented efforts to identify root causes or lessons learned are rare.
The air campaign represents a fundamental transformation of warfare that took shape in the final years of the Obama administration, amid the deepening unpopularity of the forever wars that had claimed more than 6,000 American service members. The United States traded many of its boots on the ground for an arsenal of aircraft directed by controllers sitting at computers, often thousands of miles away. President Barack Obama called it “the most precise air campaign in history.”
This was the promise: America’s “extraordinary technology” would allow the military to kill the right people while taking the greatest possible care not to harm the wrong ones.
Sadly, though, the timing of the Times in finally choosing to report what outlets like the Bureau of Investigative Journalism were writing about a decade ago was way, way off. Within 24 hours of publication, the war crimes blockbuster was knocked off the top of the digital front page by the utterly shocking news that Joe Manchin was finally done playing with the dead mouse known as the Build Back Better bill. It must be a bit of a relief that the elite movers and shakers and opinion-makers can ignore the mass drone slaughter so smoothly bragged about by Barack Obama, and instead direct all their news-cycle ire against the Democratic Party's latest designated Bad Cop. Manchin had the nerve not only to totally blindside the hapless and lackadaisical and totally complicit Biden, but to go on Fox News, of all places, to make the Big Reveal!
So Biden (who, to his credit, has reportedly greatly decreased the drone murders of innocents abroad) will react by seeming to reverse course and promising to deliver rapid Covid tests to every American household, without people having to go through a predatory insurance middleman after all! Not only that, he has also scored himself a brand new adorable puppy named Commander. Heartwarming story upon heartwarming story will make people forget all about their evictions, the resumption of their student loan payments and their lost paychecks due to the increasing number of ad hoc business closures resulting from the Fourth Wave of the pandemic.
Speaking of waves, unindicted war criminal Barack Obama was spotted cavorting in them, just as the big Times story broke, on his annual holiday vacation in Hawaii.
As the Times series on the drone slaughters and their coverups establishes - in case after case after gruesome case - there has never been any accountability. Any accountability is reserved for the exposers of war crimes, like Julian Assange and Daniel Hale, the former drone operator who was sentenced last June to 45 months in prison for the crime of leaking documents on war crimes to the press - the same kind of documents that the Times now finally sees fit to print, to little or no reaction from either the political class or from the rest of the corporate media. I guess everybody's too busy tweeting about their "mild" Omicron test results while gaslighting the unvaxxed.
Here, meanwhile, is my published response to the Times war crimes story:
As Smedley Butler observed, war is a racket. And as long as members of Congress are among the racketeers, keeping their jobs by providing their districts with military bases, weapons and bomb-manufacturing plants and jobs, and all the countless other perks associated with global, institutionalized terrorism and death, these politicians will never hold their uniformed, hideously be-medaled partners in crime accountable for the atrocities.
What this country needs is another antiwar movement. Easier said than done, of course, given the end of the military draft and the transformation of fighting forces into flying predator and Reaper drones.
At the very least, we should be able to extend our newfound anti-racist "wokeness" to the essential racism that is inherent in all of this slaughter. As Judith Butler has observed, these casualties of war - demeaned as collateral damage and "mistakes that were made" by the generals - amount to deaths that are not deemed to be grievable. No surprise that the US has refused to become a party to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, which is designed to bring justice to war criminals. In fact, Congress even passed a law that any US official arrested overseas on war crimes charges must be rescued by any means necessary. They don't even try to cloak the consciousness of their own guilt.
Revelations as published here should at least put pressure on the Biden administration to drop the charges against Julian Assange.
Well, since I wrote that comment a few days ago, Biden has announced that he is sending everybody in America a free nasal swab, calling out the troops to administer more shots, and showing off his new puppy. So let us all hold our collective breaths while we still have the breath to hold.
This article today in The Guardian is an excellent summary of how the forces of fascism are currently at work, with historical parallels:
ReplyDelete"America is now in fascism’s legal phase.
The history of racism in the US is fertile ground for fascism. Attacks on the courts, education, the right to vote and women’s rights are further steps on the path to toppling democracy."
By Jason Stanley.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/22/america-fascism-legal-phase
This morning, Amy Goodman with DemocracyNow, picked up this story.
ReplyDeleteWithout that, and Sardonicky’s earlier astute analysis, I would never have known, because of the Gray Lady’s paywall.
But a friend just gave me a digital subscription, so I checked the NYT site to read directly.
However, the astounding exposé had already disappeared.
When I asked the site’s search function for Azmat Khan, the three links below turned up, plus a slew of unrelated stories prompted by the common last name.
Thus, effectively, the NYT’s has buried the story, continuing the Pentagon cover-up.
A Pentagon Cover-Up:
Azmat Khan on How U.S. Hid Thousands of Civilian Deaths in Middle East Air War —
https://www.democracynow.org/2021/12/22/us_airstrikes_routinely_kill_civilians
December 22, 2021
U.S. air power has been central in the country’s wars in Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq and elsewhere, with officials promising that drones and other sophisticated weapons allow the U.S. military to carry out precision airstrikes that spare civilians caught in war zones. But a groundbreaking investigation by The New York Times reveals the U.S. military’s air wars have been plagued by bad intelligence, imprecise targeting and a lack of accountability for thousands of civilian deaths, many of them children. The two-part series by reporter Azmat Khan is based on a trove of internal Pentagon documents, as well as on-the-ground reporting from dozens of airstrike sites and interviews with scores of survivors. “What you have is a scale of civilian death and injury that is vastly different than what they claim,” says Khan, who spent five years on the investigation.
THE CIVILIAN CASUALTY FILES
HIDDEN PENTAGON RECORDS REVEAL PATTERNS OF FAILURE IN DEADLY AIRSTRIKES —
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/12/18/us/airstrikes-pentagon-records-civilian-deaths.html?searchResultPosition=1
Dec. 18, 2021 ~ by Azmat Khan
The Human Toll of America’s Air Wars —
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/19/magazine/victims-airstrikes-middle-east-civilians.html?searchResultPosition=2
Dec. 19, 2021 ~ by Azmat Khan
The Civilian Casualty Files —
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/us/civilian-casualty-files.html?searchResultPosition=3
Dec. 19, 2021 ~ by AZMAT KHAN, LILA HASSAN, SARAH ALMUKHTAR AND RACHEL SHOREY
"the New York Times broke out of its role as establishment mouthpiece and publicist for the powerful, and practiced some real journalism"
ReplyDeleteI doubt that. Instead, I'd ask, "Which Establishment interest is served by this act as mouthpiece and publicist?"
Within the Blob, the Drone Warriors are down. The Cold Warriors are up, trending toward sales of big ticket items even at risk of flashing off hot wars.
The big war interests have always opposed the COIN war interests. Drone war failures are highlighted, by people who do not support drone wars. These are the same people who want to replace A-10 close support aircraft with more F-35's and new generations of ABMs and super-missiles and a new generation of nukes.
When the NYT sells out, it is to the part of the Establishment with the biggest money in play. Drones and their little missiles are small time, compared to the new game in town.
ReplyDeleteThe nice thing bout drones is that they give you the creds of Zeus. According to our best authorities on classic mythology, if anyone back when annoyed Zeus too much, he let loose a thunderbolt from the sky to annihilate said annoyance. Well, the MQ-9 Reaper is just as good as any Olympian thunderbolt. Our troops, from Commander-in-Chief down to the pilot on the ground pressing a button, are justified in feeling like Zeus. Obama gave us a feel for that feeling when he bragged about the discovery that he was pretty good at killing.
Bigger bragging rights for Obama will come one day, when the trillion$plus he ordered as CiC to beef up the nuke arsenal will blow up over cities in Russia and China. Obama will then be able to share credits with Vishnu and Oppenheimer: "I am become death, the destroyer of worlds."
What? The A-10 Thunderbolts, otherwise known as "Warthogs," have been confined to the hangar so that the F-35 can get its turn at "seeing the elephant"*? Wasn't the F-35 program abandoned? Among other failures, it needed an umbrella to fly on rainy days. Russian pilots called it a flying piano. At least it supported the economy.
Biden's turn at becoming Death. He may speak words of peace and love around Christmas with his prayerful Christian vocabulary, but his actions appear to be in line with the Blob. No wonder he stutters.
*"Seeing the elephant": bragging soldier talk for having seen/escaped death itself in a real firefight. Combat deserving of pretty ribbons for dress uniforms on parade.
Today, the NYT included these —
ReplyDelete"Trump Fraud Inquiry Won’t Be Resolved When Vance’s Term Ends Next Week —
After leading a three-year investigation into the former president, the Manhattan district attorney, Cyrus R. Vance Jr., will hand it to his successor."
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/23/nyregion/cyrus-vance-donald-trump.html
Dec. 23, 2021 ~ by Ben Protess, William K. Rashbaum and Jonah E. Bromwich
"Will Donald Trump Get Away With Inciting an Insurrection?"
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/23/opinion/trump-capitol-riot-january-6th.html
Dec. 23, 2021 ~ by Laurence H. Tribe, Donald Ayer and Dennis Aftergut
The obvious answer to the latter question is an emphatic, and pathetic, YES.
Also today, sadly, we learned this:
Joan Didion, who chronicled American decadence and hypocrisy, dies at 87 —
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/obituaries/joan-didion-who-chronicled-american-decadence-and-hypocrisy-dies-at-87/2021/12/23/ca9c327a-a37a-11e5-9c4e-be37f66848bb_story.html
23 Dec. 2021 ~ by Harrison Smith
...
The press was a frequent target in her work, with Washington Post journalist Bob Woodward taking some of her most biting criticism in a 1996 essay, included in her collection “Political Fictions” (2001), that described his reporting after Watergate as mere stenography for the nation’s political elite.
….
Joan Didion, American journalist and author, dies at age 87 —
Unsparing observer of national politics and her own life, she won enormous acclaim for her memoir of grief, The Year of Magical Thinking.
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/dec/23/joan-didion-american-journalist-and-author-dies-at-age-87
23 Dec. 2021 ~ by Sian Cain
...
From the 1980s onwards, Didion focused on politics, coining the term “the permanent political class” to describe the fraternity of media, politicians and strategists that shape the US’s self-image. After Clinton’s impeachment, she wrote: “No one who ever passed through an American high school could have watched William Jefferson Clinton running for office in 1992 and failed to recognise the familiar predatory sexuality of the provincial adolescent.” Among Washington journalists, she wrote, “what ‘fairness’ has often come to mean is a scrupulous passivity, an agreement to cover the story not as it is occurring but as it is presented, which is to say as it is manufactured.”
…
In her later years, Didion wrote less; her most recent project was as the subject of Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold, a 2018 Netflix documentary made by her nephew, Griffin Dunne. Her final book, South and West, was a collection of her notes while travelling around Mississippi, Alabama and Louisiana in the 1970s; when it was released in 2017, it was marketed as a prescient take on the then newly elected president Donald Trump’s base of voters. Talking to the Guardian when it was released, Didion said: “I suppose the crisis in American politics was behind everything I was thinking, whether or not I knew I was thinking it. These things have a way of creeping in. I think we currently are living through the scariest of times.”
Like Erik Roth, I wouldn't have known about this story had I not read it summarised here.
ReplyDeleteExcellent work, Karen, covering excellent journalism and a story that all of us should read.
So sad, yet unsurprising, that the Times was so quick to bury their own story. I wish I could say I am surprised at the inaccuracy of the intelligence resulting in so much suffering but I am not.
Like Erik Roth, I wouldn't have known about this story had I not read it summarised here.
ReplyDeleteExcellent work, Karen, covering excellent journalism and a story that all of us should read.
So sad, yet unsurprising, that the Times was so quick to bury their own story. I wish I could say I am surprised at the inaccuracy of the intelligence resulting in so much suffering but I am not.
Don't forget that Obama was awarded a Nobel Peace Prize.
ReplyDeleteAnother example of global acceptance of Newspeak.
War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Igorance is strength.
After the first few months of the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan I began calling it Vietnam in the desert. And as the years rolled by, that was repeatedly proved true. The drone war was equivalent to the free fire zones in Vietnam, where any citizen was considered an enemy.
ReplyDeleteAnd of course there is the cover up.