Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Propaganda Under the Influence

Usually when we talk about State of the Union drinking games, we bet on how many times President Obama will utter such words as middle class and grit and folks during his annual song of himself.

This year we come to find out that not only has the Temp Emp not even written the speech himself, the designated populist theme is so phony that the designated hack had to go on an all-night drinking binge before he could pull it off. The speechwriter actually admits to one snort of pricey single malt Scotch over the course of his nocturnal writing marathon. That story is as old as the one about the drunk driver pleading that he only had one beer before careening the wrong way down the interstate at 100 mph.

The New York Times story about the speech story is as grotesquely phony as the actual speech itself promises to be:
One night last week Cody Keenan, the chief White House speechwriter President Obama has christened “Hemingway,” knew he needed help.
Mr. Keenan had spent 15 days holed up in a hotel room in Honolulu as the president vacationed nearby, and seven more in a windowless office in the basement of the West Wing trying to turn a blank computer screen into a 6,000-word State of the Union first draft. The lonesome process had finally gotten to him.
So the burly 34-year-old former high school quarterback left his White House office and trudged in the freezing rain to the nearby apartment of one of his closest friends in the administration, Benjamin J. Rhodes.
It was after midnight, but Mr. Rhodes, a deputy national security adviser and the writer of many of the president’s foreign policy speeches, was up reading “To Kill a Mockingbird” to his 4-week-old daughter. The two men poured two single-malt Scotch whiskies and, with the baby resting quietly, began triage on Mr. Keenan’s prose. By 5 a.m., a more succinct draft was on its way to the president.
What's more bizarre? Ostentatiously reading Harper Lee to an infant, drunk-writing a speech, or claiming that writing propaganda under the influence is a sure-fire way to make the American public feel as fuzzy as you do?
In all the policy pronouncements about tax increases on the rich and tax cuts for the middle class, Mr. Obama’s remarks are certain to address the struggles of ordinary Americans in some of the gritty, Everyman prose that has become Mr. Keenan’s trademark.
(Okay, it's already time for the first drink and it's not even lunchtime yet.)
“He reminds me of some of the folks I grew up with in the old days in Chicago journalism — those hard-bitten, big-hearted, passionate writers who brought the stories of people to life,” said David Axelrod, a longtime adviser to Mr. Obama and a former newspaper reporter.
Mr. Keenan, who is not shy but did not want to talk about himself on a day when attention is on the president, declined to be interviewed for this article.
("Nobo-o-ody knowsh, How Shy I Am,"  the hard-bitten Everyman Mike Royko wannabe folksily explained.)

Meanwhile, now that we know all about the provenance of Obama's speech,  the Times' resident Obama publicist treats us to the usual pre-propaganda propaganda. Peter Baker, apparently sober as befits his job title, nevertheless writes that Barack is "ready to move past hardship."
With the American job market surging to life, President Obama plans to use his State of the Union address on Tuesday night to effectively declare victory over the economic hard times that dominated his first six years in office and advocate using the nation’s healthier finances to tackle long-deferred issues like education and income inequality.
All right, I take the "sober" part back. Baker has to be on something in order to gratuitously accept that the nation's finances are "healthy." I think what he meant to write is that the nation's billionaires' finances are twice as healthy. The 80 richest people, nearly half of whom are Americans, now own as much wealth as half the planet. Also, in using the passive "hard times that dominated his first six years of office," Baker implies that Obama himself was not the dominant force in ramming austerity and deficit reduction down our throats. Baker echoes the canard beloved of the ruling class: that the economic meltdown was a natural disaster, not a plutocrat-made one. 
In presenting a series of initiatives aimed at the middle class, Mr. Obama hopes to pivot finally from the politics of adversity and austerity that have frustrated him for much of his tenure. But coming off a midterm election defeat that handed full control of Congress to Republicans, the president faces long odds in actually enacting his agenda and in essence is trying to frame the debate for his remaining time in power and for the emerging 2016 contest to succeed him.
Again with the Frankenstein austerity monster, for which Baker glibly grants Obama absolution for creating. The horrific monster of wealth inequality, which has grown ever larger during Obama's complicit tenure, apparently is "frustrating" the president at this late date. The country doesn't approve. So Obama is cast as a wounded warrior by the Times, rather than ordinary people being cast as the victims of his policies.
“Over the last six years, we have been weighed down by the legacy of the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression,” Mr. Obama said in a video posted on the White House website, previewing his State of the Union address. “And because of the incredible grit and resilience of the American people, America is now in a position to really turn the page.”
While you're taking your second, third or fourth drink of the day, ponder those semantics. What Obama essentially says here is that austerity worked. And since "we" have now suffered enough, in his estimation, he will now throw you a few populist crumbs. He's ready to turn the page, knowing full well that the mean old Republican librarian will stomp down on his hand before he can even take his book of forbidden magic down from the shelf. The cynicism is breathtaking, and utterly predictable.

Of course, the temporary uptick in poll numbers for the Temp Emp after his speech will make it easier for him to sell his real agenda to the newly propagandized. Instead of lobbying Congress to pass tax reform and other sweeteners to placate the base, Obama will immediately start whipping for the corporate coups known as "trade" deals. With Democratic brains softened by visions of free community college tuition and make-believe taxes on the ultra-rich (who, tellingly, are not at all howling with rage over this presidential rhetoric), the White House will go on full plutocratic attack. From The Hill:
President Obama is tasking every member of his Cabinet to round up votes from Democrats for fast-track negotiating power, which would give Obama leverage to complete trade negotiations by preventing Congress from amending his agreements.
About 80 House Democrats have been targeted in the effort, and Cabinet members are divvying up those names based on their personal relationships with the members.
The rest of the House Democratic Caucus, which consists of about 100 members, are seen as likely “no” votes.
The White House is making the push in part because of pressure from congressional Republicans.
Obama hilariously will try to claim that the Trans Pacific Partnership and its evil twin, TAFTA  (Europe) would protect American workers and the environment. Mere mortals, though, are not being allowed to see the actual details, which are being negotiated behind closed doors by the corporations benefiting from them.

His actual policy goal is in direct contradiction to his rhetorical strategy. A new report from Public Citizen's Global Trade Watch reveals that trade deals have increased wealth disparity, aggravated global poverty, driven down wages and destroyed American jobs. Obama wants fast track authority to literally undermine his own vaunted accomplishments of medical coverage for a few and minor regulations on financial predators.

Just in case your friendly congress critter is falling under the undue influence of Obama's sugar high of a speech and looming charm offensive, here's information on how to contact your reps. Tell them to Just Say No to granting him fast track authority, Just Say No to driving one more lethal stake into the heart of democracy. That heart is barely beating as it is.

12 comments:

Zee said...

Such a pity that single-malt Scotch (of whatever quality) was wasted in the concocting of the witch's brew that will be served up tonight as new and important national policy.

For my part, I intend to Just Say No to watching this evening's phony performance.

Were I to indulge in any sort of drinking game while watching, I'm sure that I would be dead of alcohol poisoning by half-time.

And even if I didn't sign up for a drinking game in advance, I'm sure that I would be drinking heavily by the end anyway.

I think that I will spend the evening reading and wait for Karen and other commentators to give me the sorry gist of the "speech" sans the requisite interruptions for applause, standing ovations, camera close-ups of sleeping members of Congress or SCOTUS, and the inevitable "shout-outs" to selected stage props--er..."honored, 'everyman,' guests"--of the Obama family.

See y'all tomorrow, hangover-free--I hope.

Daffy Pearl said...

I just started watching the State of the Union Speech and was puzzled to see Obama's skin color lighter than I remember seeing it. Even under different lights it is hard to tell he is a black man. Make up? Changing into a white man? Even the features look less black in shape. He could be a white man who had a tan from a Florida vacation. What has or is happening? Eerie.
I can't follow his speech as I find his appearance distracting. Now that he is telling us how well things are working, will his nose start growing?

annenigma said...

@Daffy Pearl

Thanks for the laugh! He's certainly lighter skinned than John Boehner.

I checked out various pictures of him during his speech and noticed the makeup line on his face. He's even whiter where the makeup wasn't applied!

When he was in Hawaii, he sure couldn't have been working on his tan unless it was to remove it. Personally, I think he's had Botox and other 'work' done, probably during his still unexplained disappearance during the Benghazi crisis.

His conversion to a White Republican is nearly complete. No wonder he plays golf instead of basketball these days. Since he turned into a White man, he can't jump!

Kat said...

What a charming story! Two men showing their softer side. But lest you think they are too feminized there is the single malt scotch and college football history. Something for everyone! Just like our president (and by everyone I mean war profiteers, bankers, and the 1%. That is everyone. That matters.)
I did not watch his speech. I already watched snatches of the link provided by Will the other day-- the MLK day of service. So now I am out cleaning the grounds of the nearest hospital as he exhorted me to do. Makes perfect sense. How will the CEO maintain his million dollar salary if we don't provide free labor?
The next step shall be the complete transformation of MLK day into a day honoring the service of our military heroes.


Kat said...

As for the free community college tuition. Over at Salon one of the morons described this as a "break with neoliberalism" and "big government".
Sure a program that represents .13% of the Federal budget is big government. And a program that completely underpins the argument that unemployment is due to lack of skills really is such huge break from neoliberalism!
So, my guess is this is the most likely one of his "populist" proposals to pass.

Ste-vo said...

Karen, Thank you for writing this. I too read the story of Cody and his all-night marathon. What a man. And then I googled him. A I read the article I felt an overwhelming sense of calmness and peace, knowing that while I was sleeping in a warm bed Cody was trudging through the frigid, rain-soaked streets of Rome on the Potomac. I found your use of the term "Everyman Grit" particularly endearing and now know why I cringe, a la George W. Bush, when I hear Mr. President Peace Prize speak. Last evening, rather than subject myself to his drivel, my wife and I chose to trudge through the frigid night on the ice-covered sidewalks of my little town to a French restaurant, one that John Kerry would be proud to eat at, for dinner with friends. By the way, I had Chicken Nicosie - delicious, and a fabulous bottle of a Spanish Rioja, that was half-price. The things restaurants have to do to court customers. And then we came home and I read a book, went to bed and now I am reading you. Thanks again.

Denis Neville said...

“All political power is primarily an illusion. Illusion. Mirrors and blue smoke, beautiful blue smoke rolling over the surface of highly polished mirrors, first a thin veil of blue smoke, then a thick cloud that suddenly dissolves into wisps of blue smoke, the mirrors catching it all, bouncing it back and forth.” - Jimmy Breslin

The Lame Duck’s mirror is rose tinted, but cracked from side to side.

Rebuilding America's middle class by fast-tracking the Trans-Pacific Partnership???

“Trust is like a mirror, you can fix it if it's broken, but you can still see the crack in that mother fucker's reflection.” - Lady Gaga

Karen Garcia said...

Obama was just a whiter shade of stale, plus the hot air emanating from his mouth created a virtual cloud around him, making it hard to discern all his bodily details. Plus, his unhealthy pallor was only accentuated by John Boehner's unhealthy bronze glow. Did you ever get a load of Boehner's wife? She's a dead ringer for the notorious Long Island Tan Addict Mom, the one who got officially banned from every tanning booth in the state.

Bert Gold, Frederick Maryland said...

For the record I knew and loved Jimmy Breslin; I even worked for him to become Comptroller of New York City at one point.

Thomas Friedman's column in the NYTimes today, focuses on Obama's apparent inability to level with himself about Islam. The column is called 'Say it like it is' (almost something Breslin could say). I rarely agree with Friedman.

There is a HUGE problem with Obama around consistency. You can't advocate for Community College for all and then double tax the 529 related plans I've used to save for school for my kids to pay for it.

You can't talk about saving US jobs and advocate for the Trans Pacific Partnership in the same breath.

Who is this guy, Obama, and how did he get my vote and my money?

Kat said...

Stev-O-- thanks for the laugh.
Pearl-- There was a strange yellowish cast to his complexion.
Anne--maybe he is tired of jumping for his corporate masters.

I read a bit of the speech. Of course a hardworking middle class family prevailed-- after sacrificing and "retooling". Nice to be likened to a factory line. But I guess that is how he sees us-- widgets in service to keep the economy moving.
Speaking of tools...

Zee said...

@Bert Gold--

I, too, wondered about the consistency of Obama's proposal to increase taxes on withdrawals from 529 college savings funds while at the same time proposing “free” community college opportunities for all.

Here's how Politico explains it:

“EDUCATION BREAKS: The administration wants to extend the American Opportunity Tax Credit, the administration’s signature higher-education tax benefit that’s scheduled to expire at the end of 2017, while making it more valuable to low-income students. Obama also wants to fix an issue in which those who join a government program that forgives student loan debt after borrowers make payments for 20 years can be socked with unexpected — and big — tax bills. That’s because the IRS considers forgiven debt to be equivalent to income and taxes it. Under the administration’s plan, that would end. Other parts of the administration’s plan would exempt Pell grants, which go to students from low-income families, from taxation.

The administration proposes to finance the breaks at least in part by taking away education breaks for the WELL-OFF. Details are thin, but the administration says it would “limit upside-down education savings incentives” by rolling back Section 529 education tax breaks created by President George W. Bush and repeal incentives for the Coverdell education savings program.”
(My bold and cap emphases.)

http://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/barack-obama-tax-plan-114367.html

Bert, you're just too “well-off,” and some of your wealth needs to be re-distributed.

As Tom Cruise's character (I think) more-or-less put it in the movie “Risky Business,” Good-bye Princeton! Hello, University of Maryland! were Obama to have his way. Which, of course, he won't.

Zee said...

@Bert Gold--

I, too, wondered about the consistency of Obama's proposal to increase taxes on withdrawals from 529 college savings funds while at the same time proposing “free” community college opportunities for all.

Here's how Politico explains it:

“EDUCATION BREAKS: The administration wants to extend the American Opportunity Tax Credit, the administration’s signature higher-education tax benefit that’s scheduled to expire at the end of 2017, while making it more valuable to low-income students. Obama also wants to fix an issue in which those who join a government program that forgives student loan debt after borrowers make payments for 20 years can be socked with unexpected — and big — tax bills. That’s because the IRS considers forgiven debt to be equivalent to income and taxes it. Under the administration’s plan, that would end. Other parts of the administration’s plan would exempt Pell grants, which go to students from low-income families, from taxation.

The administration proposes to finance the breaks at least in part by taking away education breaks for the WELL-OFF. Details are thin, but the administration says it would “limit upside-down education savings incentives” by rolling back Section 529 education tax breaks created by President George W. Bush and repeal incentives for the Coverdell education savings program.”
(My bold and cap emphases.)

http://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/barack-obama-tax-plan-114367.html

Bert, you're just too “well-off,” and some of your wealth needs to be re-distributed.

As Tom Cruise's character (I think) more-or-less put it in the movie “Risky Business,” Good-bye Princeton! Hello, University of Maryland! were Obama to have his way. Which, of course, he won't.