Friday, September 25, 2020

Pick Your Fascism

Since the pandemic is transforming the traditional Election Day into Election Season with early mail-in balloting, the Establishment's' Get Out the Vote campaign is more strident than ever.

These last few weeks of Decision 2020 feel like being swept along in a turgid stream of elite consciousness. As hard as we try to swim against the tide of the Most Consequential Election in the history of humanity, the more they try to drown us with their voter-shaming - when they're not mentally electrocuting us with their jolts of nuclear-powered gaslight.

I didn't know whether to gulp for air or melt down into an abject puddle when the Duke and Duchess of Sussex (Harry and Meghan) deigned to inform me, from the rustic grounds of their $14 million California estate, that I am allowed to "make my voice heard." 

I must use my voice to check a box to prove that I matter, Meghan nattered.

Voting will prove that I hate hatred enough to elect one of their own in order maintain "our values." And here I was, too lazy and ignorant to even realize that the magical festival of Quadrannius has finally arrived! It is that special time that comes only once every four years, when the oligarchs and celebrities go all noblesse oblige  to wake up the citizens from the cynicism and the apathy that their bitter pills have created. If we do not give them the degree of legitimacy with which to feed us even more of their bitter pills for the next four years, then they'll end up looking like the quacks they are instead of the healers they want to resemble.

To press the point home, Harry was not above playing  the guilt-tripping, gaslighting card. Give 'em hell, Harry! He reminded us with his Voice that we regular people are even more important and privileged than he is. Because as a royal personage, he has been dreadfully disenfranchised for his whole adult life!




Bertram Gross  warned 40 years ago of the "Friendly Fascism" that was taking over this country and the rest of the advanced free world. Although the parts of the book dealing with the then-bugaboos of Soviet communism and "stagflation" are dated, he was remarkably prescient about the slow, boiling-frog-death of representative democracy via an insidious corporate/oligarchic coup.

The "F" word has finally come out of the elite closet with the victory of Donald Trump. But that is only because he is an "unfriendly" fascist who rules with a sneer and a scowl instead of with the simper and the smile which has been fooling some of the people most of the time, or at least most of the people some of the time, as the frog-water simmered. Whenever the bath threatened to boil over and wake up the comatose frogs, friendly-looking presidents like Barack Obama added the requisite dose of cool charm to augment the glow of the gaslight.

Donald Trump, of course, is only adding salt to the water and gasoline to the fire. He is riling people up when they should be narcotized. He is not using what Gross called Triplespeak: the political propaganda technique comprised of "myth, jargon and confidential straight talk."

Gross wrote:

"Unlike Orwell's doublethink and newspeak, triplespeak is not part of any overall plan. It merely develops as a logical outcome of the Establishment;s maturation, an essential element of the tightening of oligarchic control."

Without myths like American exceptionalism, democracy  and the founding pioneer spirit, rulers cannot maintain order and support at the lower and middle levels of the Establishment. Jargon is required to justify the power and secrecy and violence of the military/surveillance state. Straight talk is the ploy used by elites to explain why secrecy is needed in the first place, or blather about the brutal hard truth of why social programs must be cut.

Trump, the damaged epitome of immaturity, rails against the surveillance state when it is used by his fellow elites against him. He calls vaunted military heroes "chumps and losers," while the more proper pols glorify their deaths as "the ultimate sacrifice." He directly foments violence, dispensing with all the obfuscatory jargon about human rights and morality which masks the friendly fascism his peers have striven so mightily to perfect.

And therefore, establishment media outlets are manically selling Wokeness in a valiant effort to arouse us just long enough to care about electing Joe Biden - before they put us (along with the street protests they are so eagerly covering) to sleep again, once the danger to their legitimacy passes.

Why else would celebrities and political elites be co-opting the police murder of Breonna Taylor, who lingered in obscurity until the televised murder of George Floyd made her the newest symbol of the moment? Why would the liberal establishment be able to so blithely ignore Obama's drone murders and mass deportations and police crackdowns on the Occupy movement, but now decry Trump's xenophobia and flouting of the Constitution?

It's all about the language, of course. Trump does not, as Gross's friendlier fascists do, "take over the symbols of opposition groups" and make them his own.  As the opposite of Trump's nihilistic shtick, Bertram Gross shares the secret ingredients of the friendly fascist recipe:

"Peace, equality, black power, women's rights, the Constitution, for example,are prominent in the sloganry justifying increased armament, oligarchic wealth, institutionalized white and male supremacy, and the subversion of constitutional rights."

The reason that I hope Joe Biden wins (although, with the luxury of living in a non-battleground state, I don't plan to vote for either him or Trump), is that he is often so miserably inept himself at putting a friendly face on the fascism that long preceded Trump. His campaign has had to walk back his constant stream of "gaffes" almost as often as Trump's handlers have to do damage control on his. Biden wouldn't ever be able to fool enough the people enough of the time, no matter how hard Bernie Sanders and MSNBC try to prop him, and more importantly, the Democratic Party, up.

Biden's immediate reaction, for example, to the no-bill grand jury exoneration of the Louisville SWAT team that gunned down Breonna Taylor was to warn protesters against destroying property.

And as the media very well knows, Trump can never be goaded into saying he'd accept a peaceful transition to power if he loses. Such an admission runs counter to every narcissistic fiber of his damaged being.  We'll probably be hearing Republican disclaimers of his face-saving threats from now until January and beyond, should he lose to Biden.

The first canned battle of these two snarling, smirking geriatric right-wingers will, at least, be an entertaining ratings bonanza of epic WWF proportions.

May our voices of derision finally be heard by the voter-shaming concern trolls. May our feet plod to the polls (or the mailbox) before they race right back to the streets, no matter which of these reactionary characters mounts to an ever more discredited platform of power.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Friendly or not so friendly fascism? What a choice. Such an insightful analysis and critique of our current political landscape. Great piece!

Jay–Ottawa said...


"Pick Your Fascism."

Right. What else can we do? Sticking to principle in a street fight is not an option.

After decades of arguing against the sorry idea of voting for the-lesser-of-two-evils (TLOTE), I’m now doing a one-eighty––chagrined of course––and advocating that in 2020 we all vote for the-lesser-of-two-fascists (TLOTF, i.e., the Biden gang). It was Trump himself, the man of absolutely no redeeming qualities, who made me do it.

Gurus on the left also convinced me to abandon principle: Anything! But! Trump! (ABT). Chomsky has long been for TLOTE. Nader’s latest weekly newsletter, without once mentioning Biden, again boils down to a pitch for ABT, and that means pull the lever for none other than Joe The Unsavoury Biden.
https://mailchi.mp/nader/to-democratic-voters-up-your-demands-to-trump-voters-see-how-he-didnt-deliver-for-you-81k01k6gsw?e=dac918192d

Deep blue New York State’s electoral votes are in the bag for Biden. Even so, I don’t consider myself free to submit an absentee ballot with a vote for Green Howie Hawkins or a whimsical write-in for Mickey. Punishing Trump is more urgent and life-affirming than punishing Biden. And, if I'm wrong, regretting later is preferable to regretting sooner.

Furthermore, no matter which fascist prevails in the electoral college, I want to add my vote to the likely majority vote for Biden. The more overwhelming the popular vote nationwide for Biden, the more likely Trump will accept "You're fired!" by the people. Even if Trump does not heed the pink slip, the military, aware of the landslide popular vote against Trump, will be less likely to support a Republican coup.

No matter what you do on November 3, Kierkegard offers this soothing consolation: "...one can either do this or that. My honest opinion and my friendly advice is this: do it or do not do it -- you will regret both."

chuck said...

Jay (and Karen),

Unless the Souther District of New York issues an injunction against it, all the minor parties in New York will need "the greater of 130,000 votes or two percent of votes cast" in order to maintain ballot status.

http://www.gpny.org/green_party_and_libertarian_party_file_joint_lawsuit_fighting_ballot_access_restrictions

I keep looking to see if there's any updates on the lawsuit. It was previously ruled unconstitutional, but got snuck in as a rider to the state budget.

This happened because of Andy Cuomo's spite for the Working Families party. I personally find it more important to help maintain a party status than just pad onto Biden's inevitable margin of victory in New York. But I will vote for Biden if this provision is overturned. The loss of third parties will push New York politicians like Cuomo even further to the right.

It's too late for it now, but I've also bugged friends to harangue their state reps to get the National Popular Vote Compact.

And Søren Kierkegaard (yes, I'm being a jerk and spelling his name correctly) was right.

Jay–Ottawa said...


How does it happen that famously wise parents so often spawn guileful and treacherous children? Throughout eternity we'll be hearing Solomon wailing “Absalom, my son, my son Absalom.” On a cloud nearby there’ll be Mario Cuomo crying “Andreuccio, ragazzo malvagio, ragazzo malvagio Andreuccio.”

Valerie Long Tweedie said...

I, too, am reluctantly voting for Biden. Trump is far worse than I ever dreamed he could be. I also believe it is important to have a landslide for all Democrats running for office. These nutcase right wing "protesters" who seem more like provocateurs - possibly getting financial donations from people who don't like that the protests are getting somewhere with their message? - remind me too much of Brown Shirts. I am watching on in horror in Australia and Trump's followers remind me too much of Hitler's followers. Time to try to put the genie back in the bottle.